Method Madness

Chapter 28: Critic Whispers



Helen Carter had covered three wars, two strikes, and one festival fire that still gave her hives, but nothing prepared her for the kind of violence a simple thirty-second teaser could visit on a room.

She sat second row, dead center, in a screening suite so perfectly acoustically engineered that even her own breath came back at her with a precision she found unsettling.

Around her, a dozen other critics orbited their notepads, eyes already narrowed to slits in anticipation of the coming disappointment. Warner reps stood by the back wall, arms folded, lips tight with the hope that the room would, for once, be kind.

She didn't expect to feel anything. She'd watched the viral hysteria all night, then again this morning, and arrived primed to debunk it. Carter did not believe in virality, not in the age of algorithmic manipulation. She believed in craft, intention, and the enduring capacity of human stupidity.

The lights fell. The world snapped to black, so total it killed the fidgeting of a dozen other pens. Someone in the back let out a cough, sharp and involuntary, then bit it down hard. Carter pressed her fingers to the side of her neck, feeling the metronome of her pulse, and settled in for the first strike.

The opening was nothing. Just black. But not the usual, soft, comfort-blanket black; this was a void engineered for maximum dread, a negative space that seemed to push the blood back toward her eyes. She heard her own swallow, so loud in the silence that for a second she thought the sound was coming from the speakers.

Then, the laugh.

She'd heard every Joker laugh, from Romero to Leto, and could identify them all by waveform alone. This was not a laugh; this was a slow, suffocating release, like the sound a body might make if it found itself both drowning and orgasmic at the same time.

The room went rigid. She felt it—one long spasm that rippled from front row to projectionist, a wave of attention so total that even the Warner reps forgot to breathe.

Then, at second thirty, the match. She squinted at the flare, expecting the old Nicholson cliché, but the light did not reveal anything so familiar. Instead, a face: white as ossuary dust, hair dark but the color blurring at the edges as if the light itself was not allowed to define it.

The eyes—she wanted to call them "emerald" in the press copy but it would have been a lie—were nothing so stable. The pigment was wrong, the pupil dilation wrong, the blink rate ]zero.

The smile arrived next, and she registered the slow parting of lips as a threat, not an invitation. The tongue traced the upper ridge, and every muscle in Carter's body clenched, as if the gesture was not meant for the camera at all, but for her. She felt her own mouth dry out, the tongue glued to the roof.

"You want to hear a secret?"

The voice was too close, not mixed for cinema but for whispered confessions. Carter felt the words behind her ears, then inside them.

The blackout was instant.

No fade, no comfort, just sudden, unyielding absence.

She waited for the music, the fade-in, the return to reality, but nothing came. For five full seconds, the only thing in the room was the echo of that laugh, folding back on itself in the perfect acoustics, building and building until it was either going to break or she was.

The house lights came up. Carter realized she hadn't moved her hand from her neck; the pulse there had doubled, tripled, now hammered so hard she had to let go or risk bruising.

Nobody spoke. She scanned the room: a row of veteran reviewers, all with hands hovering somewhere between their mouths and their notebooks, but none making the leap.

The man from the Times, two seats down, stared straight ahead, mouth half-open, as if he'd been interrupted in the act of swallowing his own tongue. Even the freelancer from the web had stopped fidgeting with his phone, thumb poised in the air like a dead canary.

Carter tried to make sense of her own notes, but her pen had left only a single line across the pad: a hard, straight gouge that cut through three sheets.

The first sound was a whisper, almost a croak, from the Chicago woman in the third row.

"Jesus Christ."

It was as if she'd broken a spell. Carter exhaled, the sound loud enough to draw stares from the reps in the back.

She fumbled her water bottle open, spilled half of it into her mouth, then reached for a tissue—anything to steady the tremor that had suddenly taken up residence in her left hand.

The Warner rep closest to the door made a move, as if to ask the room if they needed a reset. Nobody answered. The energy in the air was still too raw, too close to collapse.

Carter heard her own voice next, but it didn't sound like her.

"Can you run it again?"

The rep blinked, then nodded, and ducked into the projection booth.

The room returned to darkness. This time, Carter forced herself to watch with the detachment of an autopsy technician. She tried to count the frames, the cuts, the micro-movements of the face; she tried to log the precise moment when the laugh stopped being sound and became something else.

But each time she made a note, the brain rejected it. By the end of the second loop, she had a page filled with half-finished words, each one aborted before it could become analysis.

She asked for a third pass. This time, she watched the others. No one left, no one even checked their phones, which by the standards of this room was a small apocalypse.

She caught the man from the Times making eye contact with the woman from Chicago, both of them trying to communicate some deep, existential horror in a single look.

When the lights came up, nobody moved to leave. The Warner reps stood by, waiting for the questions to begin.

Carter found her voice first.

"Who is this guy?" she asked, but didn't direct it to anyone in particular.

The rep cleared his throat.

"His name is Marcus Vale. First feature. We found him in—"

Carter cut him off.

"You found him, or he found you?"

The rep paused.

"He…auditioned. Nolan signed him on the spot. We were as surprised as you are."

A soft rumble of laughter from the back, but it died before it could pick up speed.

Carter wrote the name down, then let the pen rest. She wasn't sure if her hand would obey if she tried for more.

The Chicago woman, still pale, said:

"It's like hypnosis. I didn't want to keep watching but I couldn't stop."

The Times man, finally regaining color, nodded.

"It's not acting. It's—I don't know what it is."

Someone else, a younger kid from BuzzReel, piped up:

"Did anyone else feel…watched? Like it wasn't a video, but something that could see us?"

A nervous chorus of agreement. Carter realized she'd never seen a room full of critics this off-balance, not even after the triple-feature of Lars von Trier and whatever Cannes called "midnight programming."

The Warner rep offered:

"If you'd like to see it again—"

But the group declined, almost as one. Carter shook her head, as if to clear water from her ears, then packed her notes, though she knew she wouldn't be able to read them for hours.

As they filed out, the reviews began. Small, whispered, but alive.

"That was the most hypnotic 30 seconds in cinema history," said the Times man, and Carter heard herself agreeing out loud, as if the words were a hand extended through a dream.

She left the building and stood in the midday sun, letting the afterimage of the Joker burn away, if it could.

It didn't.

The laugh still echoed, not just in her ears but in the hollow behind the ribs, where memory became story and story became the only thing worth believing in.

Helen Carter closed her eyes, felt the pulse slow, and promised herself she'd see the next trailer alone, in the dark, and only when she was ready to be haunted again.

....

Thomas Reeves had deleted the opening line seven times. Each variant was a little less honest, a little more afraid of the truth. He hunched over the laptop, one hand braced on the battered edge of the desk, the other flicking at the backspace key with the clinical precision of a surgeon removing a tumor.

Every screen in the office glowed, reflected in the glass wall behind him, so that it looked as if he were being watched by a jury of his own doubts. The headline at the top of the doc, bolded by some automaton in the digital CMS, read: "THE NEW JOKER: THE PERFORMANCE THAT BROKE THE INTERNET."

He hated it, but he was on deadline, and the only thing worse than a clickbait title was no title at all.

He played the trailer again on his phone, even though the speakers in the bullpen had been looping it for three hours. The laugh started in his right ear, traversed the length of his jaw, and then settled in his molars, vibrating at a frequency that had started to erode the enamel.

He rewound, not to the start but to the moment the match ignited. He paused on the frame—Joker's face emerging from dark like a relic, the eyes caught in mid-glare, something alive and unkind shining back through the pixel grid.

He tried to write it off as a technical trick, some digital enhancement or post-production sleight of hand, but the effect lingered. It was the same every time: the black screen, the laugh, the flare, the confession, the smile. Each pass made him feel less in control of his own reactions.

Behind him, two Deadline writers argued at the espresso machine, their voices ricocheting off the metal ductwork with the dull clangor of an argument rehearsed many times before.

"He's a method monster, mate," said the first, a wire-haired ex-pat who specialized in hatchet jobs and seemed to subsist on Red Bull and spite.

"Bet you fifty quid he never broke character for the entire shoot. Guy probably pisses with the makeup on."

"You're missing it," said the second, a woman who typed with one hand and scrolled TikTok with the other.

"It's not method. It's—" She paused, finding the word.

"It's like he got possessed. Did you see the way he stared down the lens? That wasn't for show. That was—"

The first snorted.

"Performance as haunting. Next you'll say it's method acting for ghosts."

The second shrugged.

"You'll see. They'll be teaching this in film school. If the world survives it."

Reeves tried to tune them out, but the banter stuck. He typed "possession" into the draft, then deleted it, then wrote "hypnosis" and let it linger at the end of the sentence, as if waiting for someone to rescue it.

He checked the time: twenty minutes to embargo. His editor would be pinging soon, then pinging again, each message a little less polite. The only way out was through.

He picked up the phone and called the only source that mattered. It rang, then rang again, then spat him into a voicemail so flat and American that for a moment Reeves forgot what he was going to say.

"Hi. It's Thomas, from the Guardian. Can you give me anything—literally anything—on Marcus Vale? Is that his real name? Where did you find him? Did he eat raw liver on set? Did he kill a dog to get the part? Just…call me back."

He hung up and stared at the ceiling tiles. Half of them were water stained, warped by years of busted radiators and floods from the office above. The pattern had always reminded him of a map—of rivers and archipelagos, places he'd never go.

Now the stains looked like Rorschachs, each one a face, each face with a painted mouth, each mouth wide and grinning.

He typed:

What does it mean to watch something that feels as if it's watching you?

He hated the sentence, but left it. There were worse ways to fail.

He reached for his coffee—cold, metallic, undrinkable—then put it back down. In the corner of the bullpen, someone had drawn a Joker smile on the office whiteboard; it stretched across four feet of surface, red marker starting to fade at the tips. A junior writer snapped a photo, then ran the image through three different filters before posting it to Instagram.

Reeves watched the likes rack up in real time: a dozen in a minute, then twenty, then a hundred. He thought about the old days, when reviews lived for a day and died in the next. Now every word, every frame, lived forever, or at least as long as it could be repurposed for a meme.

He glanced at the Deadline writers, now united in purpose, spooling out a top-ten list of "All-Time Joker Moments" for a midday drop. The new number one was already set: "The Laugh That Ate The Internet." Reeves wondered if he could get away with that as a pull quote.

He tried the trailer one more time, just to be sure. The opening seconds still did it: the hush, then the laugh, then the slow smile that seemed to fracture the entire idea of performance. It made him want to turn away, but also, somehow, to keep watching.

He typed, without thinking:

It's wrong how much I liked it.

He let the words hang, then leaned back and closed his eyes, letting the office soundscape wash over him.

It was all the same laugh now, looping in every room, echoing down every hallway, embedded in the pulse of every screen. In the distance, a copyeditor groaned at a dropped Oxford comma. At the other end of the building, someone sneezed, and the sound was immediately swallowed by the next round of laughter from the speakers.

Reeves took a breath, then hit send.

He opened his eyes. The grinning face was still there, burning behind the lids, waiting for the next line.

He wondered, not for the first time, if maybe the woman at the espresso machine was right.

Maybe it was possession.

Maybe that was the point.

....

Maya Lin had conducted interviews in every configuration: one-on-ones with old men who smelled of gin and rage, roundtables where egos crashed like tectonic plates, even a two-hour sit-down with Werner Herzog that left her shaking and unable to eat hot food for a week.

She believed she was immune to the theater of genius, that the human trick behind the magic was always just a trick, and that the best way to survive the freakshow was to keep your voice even, your questions direct, and your hands always, always moving.

But this was something else.

She sat in the glass-walled pavilion, a fishbowl staged for maximum visibility, with executives drifting beyond the glass, circling like the ghosts of better answers. A modest conference table separated her from Christopher Nolan, who was dressed for an English winter despite the LA sun: dark suit, open-collared shirt, no tie, hair brushed with the precise asymmetry that signaled either control or surrender. Maya couldn't tell which, not yet.

The only adornment on the table was her notepad, a battered black Moleskine, and a single microphone on a short boom arm. She clicked her pen twice, just to hear the sound. She liked the way it echoed, flat and absolute.

Nolan sat with his hands folded, not the affected steeple of a director staging a portrait, but with the patience of a man who had already decided exactly how long he would let himself be watched.

The atmosphere in the room was strange, even by industry standards. Nobody knew if the press event was supposed to celebrate the viral campaign or contain it. The Joker trailer had hit three hundred million in under twenty-four hours; half of those views, Maya suspected, were from inside the Warner firewall, but nobody said so out loud.

She shuffled her notes, checked her recorder, and asked her first question, a throwaway about process. Nolan answered it with a precision that left no space for follow-up.

Maya smiled, leaned in, and tried again.

"A lot's been made of the performance. Can you talk about how you direct someone who, from all outside appearances, seems not to need direction?"

She watched him. Nolan's eyes were an odd blue, the kind that absorbed the shape of the question and refracted it back as something less obvious.

"He is..." Nolan paused, as if translating the word from another language.

"...not just a performance. He's an answer to a question we weren't brave enough to ask."

Maya's hand froze above the page. She felt a chill run through the room, as if the air itself had stopped to listen. Behind the glass, an executive adjusted his lanyard and glanced in, sensing the shift.

She tried to keep her tone neutral.

"What's the question?"

Nolan smiled, just a tilt at the right corner of the mouth.

"What happens when the mask stops being a mask."

The words landed harder than she expected. Maya felt her own pulse, a quick thump beneath her ear, and realized she was squeezing the pen tight enough to leave an impression in the webbing of her hand.

She let it go, just a little, and tried to steer back.

"You mean, authenticity?"

He shook his head, eyes never leaving hers.

"No. I mean inevitability. Some roles aren't invented. They're remembered."

For a second, Maya lost her place. She thought of the trailer, the way the Joker's face emerged from black, the way the laugh wrapped itself around the silence, the way people in the office stopped what they were doing and just stared.

She remembered how, when she watched it last night, the light from the screen made her own face look like a mask in the darkened glass of her living room.

She tried to recover.

"You said you found him—Marcus Vale—in an open audition. Was it really that simple?"

Nolan shrugged, and this time the gesture felt genuine.

"Sometimes the world gives you the answer before you know the question. He walked into the room and everyone knew. Even the cameras."

Maya noted the way Nolan said "the cameras," not "I" or "we." As if the entire production apparatus had agency, its own will, and had chosen the actor for itself.

She glanced at the glass walls, at the faces turned inward, every person here to witness the quote, to siphon off whatever secret they could. She saw herself in the monitor's black reflection—shoulders squared, hair loose, the pen now poised and ready.

She asked her final question.

"What do you hope people will take from this version of the Joker?"

Nolan looked past her, beyond the glass, as if consulting an invisible clock. Then he said:

"That some stories aren't told. They tell us."

He nodded, just once, as if closing the case, then stood and shook her hand with a grip colder than she expected. Maya watched him leave, the shadow following like a second, better self.

She looked down at her notes. The pen had left a tremor in every line.

When the room emptied, she sat for a long time, letting the silence fill in the blanks.

She wrote the quote three times, making sure to get the cadence right:

He is... not just a performance. He's an answer to a question we weren't brave enough to ask.

She could already see it in headlines, in every column, in every atomized tweet. She felt the weight of it, the inevitability. For the first time in her life, Maya Lin realized she'd walked into a simple press event and come out changed.

She closed her notepad, clicked the pen once for luck, and left her own reflection behind in the monitor's black glass.

Outside, the world buzzed on, not knowing it had already been rewritten.

.....

This is the free chapter for hitting 50 power stones!

If you want more keep dropping reviews and power stones!

5 reviews = 1 extra chapter

50 power stones = 1 extra chapter

For Extra Chapters Visit the Patreon and Subscribe!

Currently on chapter 53 over there will be posting 10 new chapters tomorrow on patreon also.

patreon.com/BS_Entertainment98]


Tip: You can use left, right, A and D keyboard keys to browse between chapters.